Land East of Mid St
Nutfield Parish Council will keep everyone up to date on developments through this website page as and when detail comes through.
Planning Application 2026/768
Outline application with all matters reserved except access for the demolition of existing buildings and erection of up to 85 dwellings together with associated attenuation basins, landscaping and areas of public open space, at land East of Mid Street, South Nutfield Development Site East Of 131 Mid Street, South Nutfield, Redhill, RH1 5RP
Representation from Nutfield Parish Council
- The parish council OBJECTS to this planning application and asks that it be refused.
- We understand that the proposal gains some support from the policies contained in the new National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) [1]. However, granting planning consent before the emerging Tandridge District Local Plan 2024-2044 has considered the most appropriate locations for development would be premature. The site is not self-evidently sustainable and requires proper justification against alternatives.
- We also have significant concerns regarding the lack of detail in the proposals, including any adverse impact on protected species, drainage and flood risk, and sustainable travel via Mid Street. Unless and until these can be resolved, it would be unacceptable to grant even outline planning consent.
Policy Position
- The application site has been put forward as a potential allocation in the emerging Tandridge District Council (Tandridge) local plan which is now at Regulation 18 stage. A consultation on the vision and strategy for the plan is currently taking place. Tandridge has committed to submitting the plan for examination before December 2026 under the ‘legacy’ system.
- Prematurity would not normally carry significant weight as a reason for refusing an application of this size. However, Nutfield has 15 sites being assessed for potential allocation as part of the local plan, including the strategic site at Redhill Aerodrome. That would be by far the largest single allocation proposed – up to 2,250 dwellings – and meets the definition of a “strategic site” in the NPPF. The relationship between these potential allocations needs careful consideration as part of the plan process, not least to ensure that the in-combination effects are properly evaluated. That should include any impact on infrastructure that would be shared between them. Given the significance of Redhill Aerodrome in terms of housing delivery, it should be a prime consideration to ensure that nothing would prejudice that site being brought forward if Tandridge decides that it is the preferred option.
- Nothing in the application documents has given any consideration to the relationship of this site to Redhill Aerodrome or any other potential allocation. That is a requirement of the policies for decision making now set out in the NPPF. Policy HO13 (4) of the NPPF says:
Where an emerging development plan (however advanced) proposes to allocate one or more strategic sites, development proposals should not be inconsistent with the proposed scale, location and phasing of those strategic sites. This applies notwithstanding the application of policy DM4(2) where relevant.
- In the absence of any assessment of in-combination effects, or of the relationship between these two sites, this application should not be approved unless and until it is demonstrated that it would be consistent with an allocation at Redhill Aerodrome.
- As part of the evidence base for the emerging plan, Tandridge is undertaking a Green Belt Assessment. This will include a careful judgement as to which Green Belt land might also meet the government’s definition of “grey belt”, and its contribution to the overall effectiveness of the Green Belt in the area. We see this as an essential part of the evidence base for the determination of this application. The applicant has made their own ad hoc assessment of the extent to which the site meets the grey belt definition. We do not agree with the applicant’s assessment since we believe that it significantly undervalues the role the site plays in restricting sprawl. However, the only way for this to be settled appropriately is via a plan-led approach in which the whole Green Belt Assessment is taken into account. Since that information should be published shortly, the application should not be determined until it is in the public domain and can be used for decision-making purposes. Tandridge should not accept that this is a grey belt site unless that is confirmed by their own Green Belt Assessment.
- The application site lies outside the settlement boundary of Nutfield. To be approved, it must meet one of the exceptions set out in S5 (1) of the NPPF. Of those exceptions, we do not believe that it meets S5 (1) (h), because it does not lie within a reasonable walking distance of a well-connected railway station. Most of the application site is more than 800m on foot from Nutfield station, which in any case does not have a sufficient frequency of services to meet the definition in Annexe B of the NPPF.
- Because Tandridge cannot currently demonstrate a five-year housing land supply, S5 (1) (j) is relevant to the consideration of the application. However, even where S5 (1) (j) is engaged, permission may still be refused if the benefits are substantially outweighed by the adverse effects. The benefit of the scheme is limited to the provision of a relatively small number of new dwellings. On the other hand, the nature and extent of any adverse effects cannot be properly assessed. That is because a significant amount of evidence has not been submitted with the application, as we set out below.
Sustainable Location – Access and Highways
- The NPPF gives high priority to the transition to net zero in its climate change policies. CC2 requires that:
In order to contribute to climate change mitigation and the transition to net zero, development proposals should, where relevant to the proposal:
Accord with policies TR3 and TR4 so that sustainable patterns of movement are prioritised, opportunities are taken to improve walking, wheeling, cycling and public transport, and infrastructure is provided to support the transition to zero-emission vehicles;
Support good access to facilities in order to limit the need to travel, whether through the development’s location, through development densities which improve catchment populations for local services, or by incorporating community facilities and premises to support local employment opportunities
- TR3 of the NPPF itself emphasises the importance of development being located where it can support:
Sustainable patterns of movement, good accessibility for different users and make the most of existing and proposed transport infrastructure…
- The applicant’s Transport Statement acknowledges that residents of the application site would be essentially car dependent and could not benefit from walking, cycling or public transport for most of their journeys. Distances from the site to key facilities and services exceed normally accepted desirable walking distances. No proposals are included, because they are impossible, to improve links between the site and any of these facilities, for example to make cycling a safer and more attractive option. Mid Street is a relatively narrow single-carriageway road with a single footway, not designed with pedestrians or cyclists in mind. The site does not score highly when assessed using the government’s preferred Connectivity Tool, having scores of 40 or less, out of 100, for any part of the area.
- In short, the site is not well connected and would not promote sustainable patterns of movement. As such, the proposal does not accord with the most important principles of the NPPF, which is especially relevant given that the emerging local plan will identify and allocate those sites which are suitably located.
Sustainable Location – Services and Amenities
- The village primary school in South Nutfield is perennially over-subscribed and has been for over two decades. Families living more than 600 metres from the school routinely find themselves having to educate their children at schools in other local population centres. The application rate for entry to the school is regularly oversubscribed by 200% – 300% of its capacity and any parents moving to new houses proposed by this development would almost certainly have to drive their children out of the village for their education. Any parents from this development who are fortunate enough to have their application accepted for their child will simply be displacing children from other parts of the village who would otherwise have had their application accepted.
- East Surrey Hospital issued a critical incident on 12th January 2026 due to high demand and a surge in winter respiratory viruses. On 30th March a norovirus outbreak led to visiting restrictions and other control measures. On 22nd June 2026, a third critical incident was declared, caused by very high emergency-care demand with the result that non-urgent appointments were cancelled. It is clear that ESH is operating at full capacity and population increases fuelled by building projects will exacerbate the precarious position. Tandridge should seek to re-assure residents that any building permissions are accompanied by a commensurate increase in medical facilities, which should extend beyond hospital capacity to GPs’ surgeries and dental clinics.
Drainage and Flood Risk
- The Local Lead Flood Authority has already considered the applicant’s Flood Risk Assessment and Drainage Strategy [2] and made a holding objection. It has requested the submission of more information to demonstrate that there would be no risk of flooding on site or an increase in risk elsewhere, as required by F8 1 and F8 2 of the NPPF and by the consistent policies of the adopted Tandridge local plan. The applicant has also failed to demonstrate how a sustainable urban drainage system would control flow rates and runoff, as required by F8 of the NPPF.
- Flooding does occur on the section of Mid Street adjacent to the proposed site access. It is particularly important that Tandridge has full confidence that this would not be made worse by the development. We expect further information to be submitted in due course and reserve the right to make further comments.
Ecology
- The results of the Preliminary Environmental Assessment [3] found that detailed surveys are required to understand the extent of the impact on several protected species, most notably bats and great crested newts. Bat surveys were needed in relation to roosting in the existing buildings on the site, and hibernation in underground bunkers. More data was needed regarding the presence and extent of great crested newts in both terrestrial and aquatic environments. More information was also required in relation to bird species.
- None of these surveys have been completed or submitted with the application. As such, it is not possible for the adverse impacts or scope for mitigation to be assessed, and this cannot be addressed by condition or deferral to reserved matters. At present, the application can only be refused, or held in abeyance until the necessary survey results have been submitted.
Trees
- We are pleased to see that it is proposed to retain most of the important trees and hedgerows on the site. That includes the tree identified as T24 on the applicant’s survey which stands in line with the proposed access. The survey does not identify this tree as a veteran tree, but does not fully explain the criteria used for making that assessment.
- The application proposes that the access to the site is reduced to a single track as it passes T24 so that it can be retained. Whilst that is welcome, and we note that the council’s tree officer has raised no concerns, we question whether the proposed arrangement will ensure the long-term retention of the tree. Leaving aside the question of whether the root system of the tree will be adequately protected, we are concerned that residents would become dissatisfied with the constraints it imposes on access. If the application is eventually approved, this tree should be made subject to a tree preservation order.
Indicative Layout
- We appreciate that the layout plan submitted is indicative and not for approval at this stage. However the proposed parameter plan is based upon this layout and it is therefore relevant as to whether an acceptable development is proposed.
- The indicative layout is further evidence of the car-based approach the applicant has adopted. The single loop serving the majority of houses provides easy access for vehicles, but makes access to the open space difficult for the majority of residents. There are no car-free links or pathways that would enable children to reach the open space without crossing roads, or allow them to circulate in a safe, car-free environment. It is questionable whether a reserved matters application in this form would meet the requirement of the ‘Golden Rules’ set out in GB8 of the NPPF which requires that residents have access to good quality green space within a short walk of their homes. The layout should not be considered acceptable, and the parameter plan derived from it should not be accepted.
Summary
- For the reasons given above, the parish council objects to the application as it stands, and asks Tandridge to refuse planning permission. The proposal would be premature ahead of the emerging Local Plan and associated evidence base, particularly given the need to consider its relationship with other potential allocations, including Redhill Aerodrome. The site has not been shown to be a sustainable location for development, especially in terms of access, walking, cycling and public transport. There remain fundamental unresolved matters relating to drainage, flood risk, ecology and the long-term protection of important trees. In the Council’s view, the limited housing benefit of the scheme does not outweigh these significant uncertainties and potential adverse impacts as required by S5 of the NPPF, and outline consent should not be granted unless and until these matters have been properly assessed and resolved.
[1] Published 17 August 2026 (return to text)
[2] Pegasus Group May 2026 (return to text)
[3] Pegasus Group May 2026 (return to text)
NOTHING ON THIS PAGE SHOULD BE INTERPRETED AS SUPPORT FOR THIS PROJECT BY NUTFIELD PARISH COUNCIL – IT IS FOR INFORMATION ONLY.